Planning Commission debates strategies to preserve long-term housing and protect rental stock
Get AI-powered insights, summaries, and transcripts
Subscribe
Summary
Planning commissioners discussed strategies to keep long-term housing attainable, with particular emphasis on preserving existing rentals and creating incentives and expedited review paths for new affordable housing.
Lake County planning commissioners spent the latter portion of the Oct. 1 meeting discussing Goal 4 of the draft housing strategy: protecting long-term affordability and preserving the rental stock. Commissioners and staff reviewed potential tools including acquisition/covenant programs, protections for manufactured-home parks, incentives for ADUs and multifamily, and code changes to speed review of affordable projects.
Why it matters: Commissioners said preserving existing rentals and creating pathways for new, rental-oriented housing is essential to maintain a year-round workforce and to prevent displacement. Several commissioners described statewide landlord-tenant law changes and longer eviction timelines as factors pushing small owner-operators out of the rental market.
Key discussion points: - Preserve existing rentals and manufactured-home parks: Multiple commissioners urged tools to keep current rental units from being converted to condominiums or sold out of long-term rental use. One commissioner said the sale of an existing multifamily complex earlier in the county removed an important stock of long-term rentals.
- Covenants or acquisition programs: Commissioners supported exploring covenant-based protections and public-acquisition options (including land banking and public-private partnerships) so land can be conserved for long-term rental or workforce housing.
- Incentives rather than strict mandates: Commissioners stressed incentives (tax or fee relief, expedited permitting) are preferable to rigid mandates that could backfire. Commissioner Jason suggested market-linked incentives tied to recognized standards, noting that if a builder meets performance standards a longer-term property tax incentive could be considered.
- ADUs, tiny homes and targeted tiny-home communities: Commissioners said ADUs are a low-hanging fruit; code adjustments to allow ADU pathways (and to clarify when ADUs can be combined with other units) could help. Multiple speakers recommended allowing tiny-home communities or site-specific RV/tiny-home parks as targeted options rather than blanket countywide allowances.
- Expedited review and grants: Staff said the county is pursuing an expedited code amendment and a public hearing is scheduled Nov. 10 for an expedited-review path for projects that meet affordability benchmarks; the county recently obtained grant funding linked to housing commitments and staff suggested public-private partnerships and land-banking grants as tools to support multifamily.
Quotes and concerns: Heather (commissioner) described the effect of tenant-protection rules on small landlords and said, "we've had people give up their rentals for that," explaining how lengthened eviction timelines and lease-renewal rules can discourage owner-operators from continuing to provide long-term rental housing. Commissioners emphasized that protecting long-term rental stock and encouraging multifamily construction are complementary goals.
Where this leads: Commissioners asked staff to prioritize preserving existing rental stock, explore covenant/acquisition mechanisms, pursue incentives (including benchmarking successful, transferable models), and continue work on the Nov. 10 code amendment to streamline reviews for qualifying affordable projects.