The Nantucket Historic District Commission approved a plan to restore the historic porch at 149 Main Street, directing two documented conditions to ensure appropriate materials and window proportions.

Applicant Joe Paul presented historical photos from the 1930s showing a large front porch that had been previously enclosed; the proposal reopens the porch and reintroduces a recessed front door. Commissioners supported the concept, noting the photo precedent.

During deliberations commissioners asked for minor refinements. Commissioner Angus recommended dormer windows be six-light units to match traditional profiles; Commission Chair and staff noted the building's original block foundation should be acknowledged. The commission adopted a motion to approve the application as submitted with two conditions: the dormer windows shall be six-light units and the new foundation finish shall be scored to reference the existing block foundation rather than applying a full veneer.

The motion passed unanimously. Staff will coordinate details with the applicant and confirm the foundation treatment before final sign-off.