Council debates whether to tighten rules on curbside garbage and recycling storage

Councilmember Schisler asked the council to consider whether the city should require garbage and recycling containers to be stored inside garages, accessory structures or otherwise screened from street view after collection, citing constituent complaints about carts left at the curb and in front yards for extended periods.

Schisler presented Cedarburg’s ordinance as an example that requires storage within a garage or accessory structure or screened from street view. Councilmembers and staff discussed practical limits — one-car garages, snow access and owners who lack rear-yard access — and whether stricter rules would be enforceable or would impose undue burdens on residents.

Councilmember Heisler and other members reported receiving numerous constituent contacts opposing heavy-handed regulation; Heisler said many residents told him the topic is not a top priority. Some councilmembers favored stepped approaches such as renewed public education and targeted reminders to residents. City Manager Moore said code-enforcement staff already photograph violations and send notices; he urged an initial emphasis on outreach and enforcement under existing codes rather than an immediate ordinance rewrite.

Councilmember Zimmerman said the item was appropriate to bring to council as a quality-of-life issue, but indicated he would not support an overly strict ordinance without greater public buy-in. No ordinance or regulatory change was adopted; staff will consider options for education, reminders and targeted enforcement under existing rules and report back.