A contentious debate unfolded at the Virginia Marine Resources Commission meeting on September 23, 2025, as members deliberated the proposed lease of 2.3 acres for aquaculture in Warehouse Creek. The discussion highlighted significant concerns over navigation and the potential impact on local waterway users.

The applicant, Ontane Cree, defended the lease, asserting that boats frequently navigate the area and that the proposed site would not obstruct access. However, local residents, including Lisa Sejotte, voiced strong opposition, emphasizing that the lease would interfere with established navigation routes critical for both recreational and commercial vessels.

Commission members expressed skepticism about the lease, with several citing the importance of maintaining navigable waterways. Associate member Branson raised concerns about the potential conflict between the aquaculture operation and navigation, suggesting that the existing 43.8 acres already allocated for oyster grounds might be sufficient.

After extensive discussion, the commission ultimately voted to deny the application, with a 4-1 decision. The outcome reflects a commitment to balancing aquaculture development with the preservation of public access to Virginia's waterways. The commission's decision underscores the ongoing challenge of managing competing interests in marine resource use, ensuring that both economic activities and navigation rights are respected.