The Bangor Historic Preservation Commission convened on September 12, 2025, to discuss a significant request from a local homeowner in the Whitney Park Historic District. The homeowner is seeking approval to replace a failing slate roof on their 115-year-old property with slate-like asphalt shingles. This decision has sparked a debate about the preservation of historical architectural features in the community.

The homeowner detailed the challenges faced with the existing slate roof, which has required extensive repairs amounting to $13,000 over the past three years. With the original slate roof deteriorating and no local contractors willing to undertake repairs, the homeowner presented asphalt shingles designed to mimic the appearance of slate as a viable alternative. The proposed shingles, known as CertainTeed Grama Manor, are intended to provide a durable solution while maintaining the aesthetic of the historic home.

Commission members raised concerns regarding the character-defining features of the house, particularly the existing slate roof, which is considered a significant aspect of its historical integrity. The consultant's report emphasized that the slate roof has been well-maintained and is a distinguishing quality of the property. The discussion highlighted the importance of preserving the original materials and the potential impact of replacing them with modern alternatives.

The homeowner defended the choice of asphalt shingles, explaining that the selected color, "black pearl," was the closest match to the original slate, which has faded over time. They also noted that many neighboring homes have already transitioned to asphalt roofing, suggesting a trend in the area that could influence the commission's decision.

As the meeting progressed, the commission members deliberated on the implications of this request, weighing the need for preservation against the practical challenges faced by homeowners. The outcome of this discussion will not only affect the homeowner's property but also set a precedent for future renovations within the historic district.

The commission is expected to make a decision on the certificate of appropriateness in the coming weeks, which will play a crucial role in shaping the preservation efforts and architectural character of Bangor's historic neighborhoods.