A proposal to replace historic windows in a 1923 home sparked significant discussion at the El Paso Historic Landmark Commission meeting on September 18, 2025. The homeowner seeks to replace the existing metal windows with a new design featuring a 6 over 1 muntin pattern, differing from the current 6 over 6 configuration.

The owner argues that the existing windows are not original and have deteriorated over time. He emphasized that the proposed changes would maintain operability and align with the spirit of the historic district guidelines, despite the differences in design. The commission noted that there are no existing photographs of the original windows, making it challenging to determine the exact historical specifications.

Commission members expressed support for the proposal, highlighting that similar window configurations are common in the neighborhood. They confirmed that the new windows would feature three-dimensional muntins, which are preferred for maintaining the historic aesthetic.

The discussion also touched on the importance of preserving the character-defining features of historic properties, with a strong recommendation for exterior grids over interior ones to avoid glare and maintain authenticity. The commission ultimately recommended approval of the replacement windows, emphasizing the need for compatibility with the historic character of the property.

As the commission moves forward, the decision underscores the balance between modern needs and historical preservation in El Paso's historic districts.