In a meeting marked by spirited discussions and careful deliberation, the Baltimore County Landmarks Preservation Commission convened on September 11, 2025, to address significant preservation matters, including a proposal for a new fence at the historic Hensler property in Upper Falls.

As the meeting unfolded, the commission reviewed a request from property owner Tom Hensler, who sought approval for the installation of approximately 280 feet of six-foot black aluminum fencing to enclose his rear yard. The property, a circa 1853 two-story frame dwelling, is part of the Franklinville County Historic District and is characterized by its historical significance and existing wooden fencing.

Commission staff expressed concerns regarding the proposed aluminum fence, noting that it would introduce a fourth style of fencing to a property already featuring multiple existing styles, including wood and chain link. Staff recommended that the commission issue a certificate of appropriateness only if the fencing material was changed to wood, aligning with the historic design guidelines.

Hensler defended his choice of aluminum, arguing that it would better suit the neighborhood's aesthetic and provide a more open feel compared to a solid wooden fence. He pointed out that the existing chain link fence, which had fallen into disrepair, further justified his proposal for a more modern alternative.

The discussion among commissioners was lively, with differing opinions on the appropriateness of the aluminum fence versus the existing wooden style. Some members expressed a preference for maintaining the historical integrity of the property by opting for wood, while others acknowledged the practicality and visual appeal of aluminum.

Ultimately, a compromise emerged. The commission voted to approve the installation of the aluminum fence, with the condition that it would extend around the entire backyard perimeter, ensuring a cohesive look while accommodating the homeowner's desire for a less obtrusive boundary.

As the meeting progressed, the commission also turned its attention to other agenda items, including proposed landscaping and hardscaping work at the Church of the Holy Comforter in Lutherville, indicating a continued commitment to preserving the county's rich historical tapestry.

The decisions made during this meeting reflect the ongoing balancing act between modern needs and historical preservation, a challenge that continues to shape the character of Baltimore County.