The Preservation Commission of Evanston convened on September 9, 2025, to discuss alternative designs for a proposed access ramp to the dog beach area, following significant community feedback and previous concerns regarding environmental impact. The meeting focused on two main alternatives presented by GEI Consultants, which aimed to minimize disruption to the natural landscape while ensuring ADA compliance.

The first alternative involves a ramp that provides access without bisecting the dune to the north, specifically designed for the dog beach area. The second option is a more temporary solution, utilizing mats and an aluminum ramp that can be repositioned annually based on lake levels. Both alternatives were developed in response to earlier pushback from the commission regarding a more intrusive original design that would have impacted the natural area.

Commission members expressed appreciation for the new proposals, noting that they align better with the commission's preservation goals. Mary Resinsi, a member of the Parks and Recreation Board, highlighted that the board unanimously rejected the original plan in favor of designs that do not disrupt the natural area. The commission discussed the importance of maintaining visual access to the lakefront while ensuring safe and accessible pathways for the public.

During the meeting, members debated the merits of the two alternatives, emphasizing the need for minimal alteration to the historic lakefront. There was a consensus that the new designs were a step in the right direction, with many members expressing a desire to formally acknowledge the city council's responsiveness to their previous recommendations.

While the commission does not have binding authority over the project, they discussed the possibility of issuing a letter of support for the preferred alternative, which would reinforce their commitment to preserving the character of the lakefront. A show of hands indicated unanimous support for the alternative that minimizes visual impact and adheres to the commission's standards.

The meeting concluded with a sense of optimism regarding the ongoing dialogue between the commission and city officials, as members expressed satisfaction with the progress made in addressing community concerns. The commission plans to continue monitoring the project's development and will provide further input as necessary.