In a charged atmosphere at the Shelby County Commission meeting on September 8, 2025, community members voiced their strong opposition to a proposed jail in New Chicago, a historically Black neighborhood. The meeting, marked by passionate public comments, highlighted deep-seated concerns about the implications of such a facility in a community already grappling with significant social and health challenges.

As the evening unfolded, speakers took to the podium, expressing their fears and frustrations. One resident, William Edwards, passionately recounted the historical injustices faced by Black individuals in the area, linking the proposed jail to a legacy of systemic racism and neglect. "How could you sleep at night if you vote to put a jail in a historically Black community?" he implored the commissioners, emphasizing the need for thoughtful consideration of the community's well-being.

Amber Sherman, another vocal opponent, criticized the commission for limiting public comment time, arguing that it undermined the democratic process. She pointed out the troubling dynamics of a predominantly white leadership proposing a jail in a majority-Black area, calling it a "disgusting" disregard for community voices.

Keishaan Pearson echoed these sentiments, highlighting the pressing public health crisis in Southwest Memphis and advocating for investments in clean energy and community development instead of incarceration. "We do not need new jails. We need new clean energy sources," she asserted, urging the commission to prioritize the community's needs over punitive measures.

The meeting also saw support from organizations like the Justice and Safety Alliance, which called for a rejection of the jail proposal, arguing that it would only exacerbate existing challenges in New Chicago. They emphasized the importance of addressing root issues within the jail system rather than perpetuating cycles of mass incarceration.

As the night drew to a close, the commissioners faced a pivotal decision that could shape the future of New Chicago. The voices of the community rang clear: they seek not a jail, but a commitment to healing and development that honors their history and aspirations. The outcome of this meeting could have lasting implications for the residents of Shelby County, as they continue to advocate for a future built on justice and equity.