The Senate Judiciary Committee convened on March 8, 2025, to discuss key legislative matters, including the validation of a scoring instrument used for evaluating the release of individuals under supervision. The meeting began with a focus on the Compass assessment tool, which is designed to assess a person's criminogenic risk and support systems. This tool has been validated for relevance to New Mexico populations, as confirmed by a committee member.
A comparison was made between the Compass assessment and the Arnold tool, with committee members noting that the Compass tool is considered significantly more credible. The discussion highlighted the importance of using validated instruments to ensure fair evaluations in the judicial process.
Another significant topic addressed was the endorsement of the legislation by the Sentencing Commission. A committee member expressed appreciation for the diverse representation within the commission, which includes prosecutors, public defenders, and judges. The member emphasized the need for the administration to consider the commission's perspectives, especially regarding legislation that may impact sentencing structures.
Concerns were raised about proposed felony possession legislation that would eliminate good time credits, which are seen as crucial for modifying behavior and reducing recidivism. The committee member urged the administration to recognize the value of good time as an effective tool in the justice system.
Following the discussions, the committee moved to pass the legislation, with a vote resulting in a majority in favor, although Senators Thornton and Paul voted against it. The meeting concluded with the announcement that there would be no further meetings scheduled for the following day, allowing members to enjoy their weekend.