Winery Owners Urge Planning Commission to Protect Small Business Rights in Santa Clara County

The Santa Clara County Planning Commission meeting on August 28, 2025, highlighted significant concerns from local winery owners regarding proposed changes to agricultural classifications that could impact their businesses.

Larry Imus, co-owner of L and M Vineyard in Gilroy, expressed his worries about the county's report, which noted that some facilities operate under existing wine classifications with minimal ties to actual wine production. Imus emphasized that small wineries like his adhere to regulations and should not be penalized for issues that should be resolved through existing codes.

Vicky Kermoyan, co-owner of P and V Winery in Coyote Valley, shared her perspective on the importance of small businesses in the community. She urged the commission to consider the cultural and social roles that wineries play, serving as gathering places for families and preserving agricultural heritage. Kermoyan requested that any issues with specific locations be addressed individually rather than imposing broad restrictions that could threaten small wineries' rights.

Her partner, Paul Carmoyne, echoed these sentiments, criticizing the vague language in the proposed changes. He called for clearer, more specific guidelines that accurately reflect existing codes and the realities of local agricultural practices. Carmoyne highlighted the complexity of code writing and the need for precision to avoid unintended consequences for local businesses.

The discussions underscored the delicate balance the Planning Commission must strike between regulatory oversight and supporting the local agricultural economy. As the commission considers these changes, the voices of small winery owners will be crucial in shaping policies that protect their interests while ensuring compliance with state regulations. The outcome of this meeting could have lasting implications for the future of Santa Clara County's wine industry and its community fabric.