The San Antonio Zoning Board of Adjustment convened on May 5, 2025, to discuss a variance request concerning a residential carport that has been a source of contention between neighbors. The applicant, who has had the carport in place for nine years, sought approval for its front and rear structures, as well as a side addition. The applicant argued that the carport was built to protect vehicles from weather damage and provide a safe play area for children, emphasizing that it was constructed with safety in mind and did not encroach on neighboring properties.

During the meeting, board members reviewed photographs and discussed the carport's proximity to property lines. The applicant stated that the structure was built six inches from the property line and designed to direct water runoff away from neighboring homes. However, concerns were raised by a neighbor, Arlene Garcia, who claimed that the carport's construction had caused significant water runoff issues, damaging her home’s foundation and leading to structural problems. Garcia argued that the carport was built without proper permits and requested that it be moved or modified to prevent further damage to her property.

The board heard conflicting testimonies regarding the impact of the carport on Garcia's home. While the applicant maintained that the runoff issues originated from Garcia's property, she insisted that the carport was the cause of her home's foundation problems. The applicant expressed a willingness to install gutters to manage water runoff, which Garcia indicated could be a potential solution.

The meeting highlighted the challenges of balancing property rights with neighborhood concerns, as board members considered the implications of the variance request. The discussion underscored the importance of adhering to zoning regulations and the potential consequences of non-compliance. The board is expected to deliberate on the matter further, weighing the testimonies and evidence presented before making a decision on the variance request.