Residents of St. Augustine are set to see changes in their neighborhood as the Planning and Zoning Board approved a variance request for a porch addition at a corner lot on Oneida Street during their May 6, 2025 meeting. The decision aims to reduce the impervious surface area of the property while addressing the needs of a family with young children.

The property, which currently has a 79% impervious surface ratio due to a fully paved rear yard, will see the removal of a significant portion of concrete pavers. The proposed porch, designed to match the existing architectural character of the home, will cover less than half the size of the current paved area, reducing the impervious surface to below 70%. This change is expected to create a more usable outdoor space for the family while also improving drainage and reducing flooding risks in the area.

Despite the positive aspects of the proposal, concerns were raised by several neighbors regarding the potential visual impact of the new structure. Out of 23 notices sent to nearby residents, three opposed the addition, citing issues with height and proximity to property lines. One neighbor expressed worries that the porch would obstruct views and create an imposing presence in the neighborhood.

In response to these concerns, board members discussed the possibility of adjusting the porch's design to better align with the existing structure and minimize its footprint. The applicant indicated a willingness to modify the plans to address the board's feedback, particularly regarding the setback on the north side of the property.

Ultimately, the board approved the variance with the understanding that the porch would be constructed in line with the existing house and that all existing pavers would be removed, further enhancing the property's compliance with zoning regulations. This decision reflects a balance between individual property rights and community concerns, emphasizing the importance of maintaining neighborhood character while accommodating family needs.

As the project moves forward, residents can anticipate a transformation that not only benefits the homeowners but also contributes to the overall aesthetic and environmental health of the area.