Maui County's Housing and Land Use Committee convened on June 23, 2025, to discuss Bill 9, a proposed measure aimed at addressing the ongoing housing crisis exacerbated by short-term rentals (STRs). The bill has garnered strong support from community members who argue that it is a crucial step toward correcting longstanding injustices related to land use and housing availability.

Testifiers at the meeting, including Holly and Jackie Keith, emphasized the need for Bill 9 as a response to the detrimental impact of STRs on local residents. Holly, a longtime resident, expressed her belief that the bill represents a small but significant move toward justice for the Hawaiian people, whose land has been historically taken from them. She urged newcomers to Maui to recognize the implications of their presence and the need for equitable solutions.

Jackie Keith, a transplant from Massachusetts, echoed these sentiments, highlighting the bill's role in addressing the exploitation of housing for profit rather than community well-being. She criticized the notion that tourism is an unchangeable economic foundation, arguing instead for a vision rooted in sustainability and dignity for local residents. Keith pointed out that the current housing market is inflated by commercial investments, which prioritize profit over the needs of the community.

The committee's discussions also touched on the need for a transparent rezoning application process for STRs, allowing residents to challenge inappropriate zoning decisions. Testifiers underscored the urgency of the situation, noting that the bill has been under consideration for several months and that delays only serve to prolong the crisis faced by local families.

As the committee moves forward, the implications of Bill 9 could reshape the housing landscape in Maui, prioritizing the needs of residents over the interests of investors. The community's call for action reflects a growing demand for policies that protect local livelihoods and ensure that housing serves its intended purpose: to provide shelter and stability for the people of Maui.