The Bay City Commission convened on August 5, 2025, to discuss a resolution concerning the execution of no-knock warrants, a topic that has sparked significant debate within the community. The meeting highlighted various perspectives on the implications of such warrants for both law enforcement and civilian safety.

The discussion began with a commissioner emphasizing the importance of transparency regarding the execution of no-knock warrants. They noted that while some details may be considered trade secrets, the public could request information through a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request, although much of it might be redacted. The commissioner argued that the resolution aims to protect both civilians and law enforcement officers, suggesting that those opposed to the resolution inadvertently support its necessity by expressing concerns about the dangers of executing no-knock warrants.

Another commissioner, Coakley, sought clarification from the safety director regarding the definition and execution of no-knock warrants. The safety director explained that the term is often misunderstood; officers are required to announce their presence as they execute a warrant, but a no-knock warrant allows them to enter without waiting for a response. He noted that the Bay City Police Department has executed only four no-knock warrants since 2021, with none occurring in 2023, indicating that such warrants are rarely used due to their high-risk nature.

The safety director expressed concern that if the resolution were to pass, it could hinder the ability of local law enforcement to collaborate with the Michigan State Police on high-risk search warrants. He warned that without the option for no-knock warrants, the state police might decline to assist in critical situations.

The meeting concluded with a recognition of the need for further discussion on the resolution, as commissioners weighed the balance between public safety and the rights of individuals. The commission plans to revisit the topic in future meetings, reflecting the ongoing dialogue about law enforcement practices in Bay City.