The Toledo Public Safety & Criminal Justice Reform Committee convened on July 29, 2025, to discuss critical issues surrounding police presence and community safety, particularly in relation to the city's substations. The meeting highlighted various perspectives from council members and community representatives regarding the effectiveness of police operations and the need for enhanced safety measures across different districts.

The session began with a proposal from a council member to transform a resolution into an ordinance aimed at improving police protection in Districts 1, 4, 5, and 6. The proposed ordinance included a budget of $400,000, which could potentially be increased with available funds from the general fund and the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA). The council member expressed urgency in moving this ordinance to the next agenda for expedited passage.

Community members, including Julie Buckley, voiced their concerns about rising violence and the importance of a visible police presence to deter crime. Buckley emphasized the need for a safe environment for families and children, reflecting a broader sentiment among residents who desire a secure community.

Richard Arnold brought attention to the upcoming tenth anniversary of the death of Falco, a police dog killed in the line of duty. He urged the council to commemorate this event, highlighting its significance in uniting the community during a time of turmoil.

Councilman Torres raised concerns about the administration's shift in police presence, questioning the decision to close the D. Michael Collins Northwest District Station. He cited recent violent incidents in West Toledo and called for clarity on the city’s priorities regarding public safety.

In response, Councilman Melvin defended the administration's approach, emphasizing the complexity of crime prevention and the need for thoughtful solutions rather than reactive measures. He pointed out that the timing of violent incidents often does not correlate with police station operations.

Councilwoman Williams shared her personal experiences with crime in District 4, asserting that despite police presence, crime rates remain high. She advocated for stronger community engagement as a crucial element in addressing safety concerns.

The meeting concluded with a commitment from the council to consider the diverse viewpoints presented and to work towards effective solutions for public safety, particularly in areas identified as high-risk. The discussions underscored the ongoing challenges Toledo faces in balancing police presence with community needs, as well as the importance of fostering a collaborative approach to crime prevention.