In a recent Quarterly Commission Meeting held on July 25, 2025, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals addressed several significant issues concerning forensic laboratories and their operations. The meeting, marked by a series of self-disclosures and recommendations, highlighted the ongoing commitment to maintaining integrity and accuracy within forensic science.
One of the key discussions involved the dismissal of an analyst from the Bexar County laboratory due to fraudulent overtime claims. Following an internal investigation, the commission decided to take no further action, citing the analyst's separation from the lab as a sufficient resolution.
Another notable incident was reported by the Quality Forensic Toxicology Lab, where a technician mistakenly installed equipment incorrectly, leading to erroneous reports. The lab's thorough recalibration and root cause analysis prompted the commission to recommend no further action, recognizing the lab's proactive measures to rectify the situation.
The meeting also addressed issues at Sorenson Forensics, where a former CEO had directed analysts to conduct case reviews without proper documentation. The lab is currently investigating this matter but has not identified any affected Texas cases. The commission supported the lab's corrective actions and recommended no further action.
Additionally, NMS Labs disclosed multiple instances of an analyst mishandling case numbers, attributed to pressure to meet deadlines. The analyst has since resigned, and the commission found no impact on the testing performed, leading to a recommendation for no further action.
The Center for Human Identification reported a contamination incident involving DNA samples, which raised concerns about the integrity of evidence. The commission decided to table this disclosure for further information, emphasizing the need for a comprehensive follow-up.
Throughout the meeting, the commission consistently emphasized the importance of transparency and accountability in forensic practices. They commended laboratories for their thorough root cause analyses and corrective actions, reinforcing the message that maintaining high standards is crucial for the credibility of forensic science in Texas.
As the meeting concluded, the commission's recommendations reflected a commitment to continuous improvement and vigilance in the face of challenges, ensuring that forensic laboratories uphold the integrity of their work for the justice system.