A significant discussion unfolded at the Design Review Board meeting in Laguna Beach on July 24, centering on a proposed project at 411 Holly Street. The project, which includes a garage and additional parking, sparked a debate over the historic status of the property.

Architect Tim Nicholl presented the project, emphasizing its minimal impact on the street and the preservation of the existing pedestrian entry feature. He confirmed that the chimney height had been reduced to comply with regulations, stating, “We agreed to keep it to that height, and reduce the size of it.” However, concerns were raised by community member Anne Christophe regarding the property's historical significance. She argued that the property meets criteria for local historic designation and urged the board to delay approval until a thorough evaluation of its historicity could be conducted.

In response, project supporter Larry Noakes countered that the property does not qualify as a historic resource under current regulations, asserting, “It’s not a mandatory or presumptive historic resource.” He urged the board to approve the project, highlighting the owners' long-standing commitment to responsibly remodel the house.

After public comments, board members expressed their support for the project, noting its compatibility with the neighborhood and the quality of design. Board member Weil remarked, “I think this is just a beautiful little touch up to some elements of this home,” while others echoed similar sentiments, emphasizing the project’s alignment with community standards.

Ultimately, the board moved to approve the design review, revocable encroachment permit, and coastal development permit, paving the way for the project to proceed. The decision reflects a balance between community concerns over historical preservation and the need for modern development in Laguna Beach.