The Maui County Housing and Land Use Committee reconvened on July 23, 2025, following multiple previous meetings, to continue discussions on critical housing legislation. The meeting began at 9:00 AM, focusing on the implications of Bill 9 and its potential impact on housing development in the region.

Member Cook initiated the discussion by raising concerns about the legal aspects of the proposed bill, particularly regarding the three to five-year timeline for property owners to adapt to new regulations. Cook questioned how potential amendments, such as upzoning certain properties, would affect the legal framework of the bill. Legal counsel clarified that upzoning would generally enhance property value and would not be subject to the phase-out timeline, as it only applies to apartment districts.

The conversation then shifted to the pressing housing needs in Lahaina, where members discussed the possibility of adjusting timelines based on regional demands. There was a proposal to create a Task Implementation Group (TIG) to evaluate different criteria for housing development, ensuring affordability for residents. Members expressed the need for a comprehensive approach that balances fiscal responsibility with the emotional aspects of housing security for the community.

Further discussions included the necessity of ancillary bills to support the main legislation, emphasizing the importance of having a variety of tools available to address housing challenges effectively. Members acknowledged the fiduciary duty to maintain the county's financial health while ensuring that residents have access to affordable housing.

The meeting concluded with a commitment to continue refining the bill and exploring additional strategies to meet the housing needs of Maui County residents. The committee plans to reconvene to further discuss the implications of the proposed legislation and the next steps in the process.