Owners Push to Rescind Landmark Status of 447 Battery Street for New Development

The San Francisco Historic Preservation Commission faced a pivotal decision during its recent meeting regarding the landmark status of 447 Battery Street, a building with a rich history and significant community ties. The commission heard passionate testimonies from local business owners and residents urging them to uphold the landmark designation, which was granted just three years ago.

Danielle Kuznic, owner of the San Francisco Wine Society, expressed strong opposition to the proposal to rescind the landmark status, arguing that the building's historical significance should not be compromised for a new high-rise development. She highlighted the building's past, noting that it was designated a landmark to protect it from demolition, particularly in light of a failed redevelopment project for an 18-story tower. Kuznic emphasized the importance of preserving the building not only for its architectural value but also for the community it supports.

Other speakers echoed her sentiments, stressing that the landmark designation is vital for maintaining the character and history of San Francisco. Rhoda Schneiderman, a resident living nearby, pointed out that any new project should incorporate the landmark building rather than erase it entirely. She suggested that the city could explore alternative designs that would allow for both a new fire station and the preservation of the historic structure.

Catherine Petron, representing San Francisco Heritage, underscored the unprecedented nature of delisting a landmark building, urging the commission to consider the broader implications for historic preservation in the city. She called for a financial mechanism to balance the loss of such landmarks, advocating for a thoughtful approach to urban development that respects the city's heritage.

The commission's discussion also touched on the procedural aspects of the decision, with members acknowledging the importance of their recommendation to the Board of Supervisors. Several commissioners expressed their commitment to preserving the building, citing its role in telling the story of San Francisco's blue-collar history and its architectural significance.

As the meeting concluded, the commission faced the critical task of deciding whether to uphold the landmark status of 447 Battery Street. The outcome of this decision will not only impact the future of the building but also set a precedent for how San Francisco navigates the balance between development and preservation in the years to come. The commission's recommendation will be forwarded to the Board of Supervisors, where further discussions will take place regarding the future of this historic site.