In a recent meeting of the Saratoga Design Review Commission, significant discussions centered around proposed modifications to a historic property at 202 Lake Avenue. The meeting highlighted the delicate balance between preserving the architectural integrity of historic homes and accommodating modern updates.

The property owner, represented by Antonia Yasenchak of American Y Engineering, presented plans to upgrade the existing front porch, which included replacing the current roof with a standing seam metal roof, adding a new column, and refacing existing concrete pilasters with stone. The proposal aimed to enhance the home's aesthetic while addressing maintenance challenges posed by the current materials.

However, the commission members expressed concerns regarding the potential impact of these changes on the home's historical character. Many members voiced strong opposition to the addition of stone cladding on the pilasters, arguing that it would disrupt the proportions and historical accuracy of the structure. The existing concrete, while aged, was deemed an integral part of the home's charm and historical narrative.

The discussion also touched on the proposed removal of cheek walls and the replacement of lattice work. While some members supported the lattice replacement with a simpler design, there was a consensus that the cheek walls should remain intact, as they contribute to the home's defining features.

The commission's feedback indicated a preference for maintaining the existing materials wherever possible, emphasizing the importance of historical accuracy in renovations. The majority favored either an asphalt roof or a flat seam metal roof over the proposed standing seam option, citing concerns about its appropriateness for the home's architectural style.

As the meeting concluded, the commission encouraged the property owner to consider the historical context of the home in their renovation plans. The discussions underscored the ongoing challenge of balancing modern needs with the preservation of Saratoga Springs' rich architectural heritage. The commission looks forward to further discussions as the property owner refines their proposal in line with the feedback received.