In a recent meeting of the Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB) in St. Augustine, members engaged in a thorough discussion regarding a proposed development on Saint George Street, emphasizing the importance of maintaining the city's historic character while addressing modern needs. The board's deliberations highlighted concerns about stormwater management, architectural aesthetics, and the integration of green spaces.

One of the primary topics was the project's lot coverage and its potential impact on stormwater retention. Board members expressed the need for effective stormwater solutions to mitigate flooding, a significant issue in the area. The developers indicated ongoing discussions with public works to explore options such as pervious pavers and underground retention systems, aiming to maximize stormwater management.

A key point of contention arose around the design's exterior elevations. Board member Catherine Duncan noted that the current design lacked visual appeal and suggested that the layout could be adjusted to enhance the garden's prominence, which she described as a vital aspect of the site’s character. The board emphasized the need for the design to reflect the historical context of the area, ensuring that new constructions complement existing architecture without imitating it.

The board also discussed the possibility of flipping the site plan to create a more inviting garden space that opens towards the streets, which could improve the overall aesthetic and functionality of the development. This suggestion was well-received, as it could help reduce the perceived massing of the buildings.

Ultimately, the board voted to continue the application for the project, allowing the developers time to refine their plans based on the feedback received. The next meeting is scheduled for August 20, where the developers are expected to present revised designs that align more closely with the board's vision for maintaining St. Augustine's historic charm while accommodating necessary modern developments.

This meeting underscores the ongoing efforts of the HARB to balance growth and preservation in St. Augustine, ensuring that new projects enhance the community's character and address practical concerns such as stormwater management. As the city continues to evolve, the board's commitment to thoughtful and context-sensitive design remains crucial for the future of St. Augustine.