In a recent meeting of the Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB) in St. Augustine, the board discussed a significant case involving the after-the-fact approval for the wholesale replacement of windows at a historic property located at 40 Sanford Street. The building, constructed in 1884 and part of the Lincolnville National Register Historic District, underwent window replacements without the necessary permits, raising concerns about adherence to local preservation standards.

The property owners, Tyler Woods and Christine Klobenstein, explained that they were unaware of the permit requirements when they replaced the windows. They had contracted with New South Windows, who submitted a permit application, but the work was completed before the permit was issued. This miscommunication has sparked a broader conversation about the responsibilities of homeowners in historic districts and the importance of understanding local regulations.

During the meeting, board members expressed their disappointment over the loss of original wood windows, which are integral to the character of historic homes. While two community responses were in favor of the window replacement, one expressed concerns about the changes made to the property. Valerie Byrd, a community member, noted the importance of maintaining the beauty of historic homes for future generations.

The board ultimately discussed the implications of the window replacements on the building's historic integrity. They emphasized that homeowners must be aware of the regulations governing renovations in historic districts, as ignorance of the law does not exempt them from compliance. The board's decision will hinge on whether the new windows can be deemed compatible with the historic character of the structure.

This case highlights the ongoing challenges faced by homeowners in historic districts, particularly regarding the need for education about preservation laws. As the board deliberates on the approval of the certificate of demolition for partial demolition, it underscores the importance of clear communication and adherence to regulations to protect the historical fabric of St. Augustine's neighborhoods.