The St. Augustine Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB) convened on July 15, 2025, to discuss a significant proposal regarding the construction of a new convent building on the site of the former St. Joseph Academy. The proposed structure, standing at 46 feet, aims to replace demolished academy buildings and will be located adjacent to the historic Sisters of St. Joseph Convent, which dates back to the 1870s.

The new design incorporates elements of Mediterranean and Gothic Revival architecture, featuring an arcaded loggia and stained glass windows. The project seeks to maintain harmony with the existing convent's architectural style, which includes multi-light wood casement windows and a stucco exterior. The proposed building's orientation is designed to minimize impacts on nearby historical structures, including the Caveto House ruins.

HARB members expressed concerns regarding the potential archaeological impact of the construction, as the site is located within a sensitive archaeological zone. Previous excavations in the area have uncovered significant historical artifacts, and the board emphasized the need for close coordination with the city archaeologist to mitigate any damage during construction.

Additionally, the applicant must secure variances from the Planning and Zoning Board (PZB) to exceed height and yard requirements. HARB's recommendation will play a crucial role in the PZB's decision-making process.

The board concluded the meeting by outlining two possible actions: approving the project if it meets architectural guidelines or continuing the application to allow the applicant to provide further details. The applicant is scheduled to present at the next PZB meeting, where the future of this significant construction project will be further evaluated.