Lexington homeowners oppose Barnes' short term rental permit due to deed restrictions

In a recent meeting of the Lexington Board of Adjustment, a proposal for a short-term rental in the Green Hills Subdivision has sparked significant debate among community members. The board is currently considering an application from Taylor and Alex Barnes, who wish to operate a short-term rental at their property, despite the presence of another rental within the required 600-foot buffer zone.

City staff recommended disapproval of the application, citing that the Barnes' property does not meet any of the relief provisions outlined in the zoning ordinance. According to the staff's analysis, the area currently has one short-term rental operating within the buffer, and the percentage of unhosted rentals in the neighborhood is only 0.23%, well below the 2% threshold set by local regulations.

During the meeting, the Barnes presented their case, emphasizing their commitment to being responsible neighbors and maintaining strict rules to minimize disturbances. They highlighted their plans to manage the property remotely, with local assistance available to address any issues that may arise. The couple expressed their desire to contribute positively to the community and support local businesses by hosting guests.

However, opposition from the Master Sensation Homeowners Association was strong. Jeff Swain, the association's vice president, voiced collective concerns from residents regarding the potential for noise and nuisance associated with short-term rentals. He pointed out that the property is subject to deed restrictions that prohibit business operations and emphasized the association's commitment to enforcing these rules. Swain also raised issues about the city's process for granting conditional use permits, claiming that several properties in the area may be operating without proper approval.

The board's decision on the Barnes' application will have implications not only for the couple but also for the broader community, as it reflects ongoing tensions between property rights and neighborhood regulations. As the city continues to navigate the complexities of short-term rentals, residents are keenly aware of how these decisions will shape their community's character and livability. The board is expected to deliberate further before reaching a conclusion on this contentious issue.