Taxpayer Graham Harvey challenges property valuation at Board of Review hearing

The City of Waukesha's Board of Review convened on July 11, 2025, to address property assessment appeals, a critical process for ensuring fair taxation in the community. The meeting focused on a significant case involving a property valued at $10,053,000, which the taxpayer contested, presenting an alternative valuation of $8,240,000.

During the proceedings, Graham Harvey, representing the taxpayer, outlined his assessment methodology, which included an income analysis based on data provided by the property owner. Harvey emphasized the importance of using a cap rate of 7%, derived from current realty rates, to arrive at a more accurate valuation. He noted that the proposed assessment reflected a 23% increase from the previous year, raising concerns about its justification.

The Board of Review, composed of city officials, reiterated its legal obligation to uphold the assessor's valuation unless the taxpayer could provide compelling evidence to support a different figure. This burden of proof is crucial, as the board cannot make assumptions about property values. The process allows for a structured exchange where the taxpayer presents their case, followed by questions from both the assessor's office and the board.

The discussions highlighted the ongoing challenges of property valuation in Waukesha, particularly in a climate of rising property values. The outcome of this appeal could set a precedent for future assessments and impact the financial responsibilities of property owners in the city.

As the meeting concluded, the board's decision on this appeal remains pending, with implications for both the taxpayer and the city's revenue from property taxes. The Board of Review's commitment to transparency and fairness in the assessment process underscores its role in maintaining equitable taxation practices in Waukesha.