The Historic Landmark Commission meeting held on July 10, 2025, in El Paso, Texas, focused primarily on the proposed window replacements for a historic property constructed in 1929. The discussion began with an overview of the existing windows, which include various types, primarily wood and sash windows. The owner’s proposal for new windows was presented, highlighting the need for replacements due to the degradation of the original materials.

The commission noted that while the replacement of windows is generally acceptable, the proposed new windows do not exactly match the original types. The owner suggested double-hung windows with a 6 over 1 light configuration and some sliding windows. The commission expressed concerns regarding the sliding windows, as they are not considered original or historic window types. It was indicated that while sliders might be acceptable on less visible areas of the property, they are not typically approved for main facades.

The commission emphasized the importance of maintaining the historic character of the property, stating that any replacement windows should closely resemble the original in style, operation, and finish. Guidelines were referenced, which recommend that if windows are damaged beyond repair, replacements should match the original types, such as double-hung styles, and should not include single-pane or horizontal sliding windows unless they were part of the original design.

The discussion also covered the significance of preserving original architectural features, including doors and windows, which are considered character-defining elements of historic properties. The commission reiterated that repairs should be prioritized over replacements whenever feasible, and any new installations should be compatible with the existing structure.

In conclusion, the commission recommended approval of the window modifications, provided that the new windows align with the established design guidelines. The meeting underscored the balance between necessary updates and the preservation of historical integrity, ensuring that any changes respect the architectural significance of the property. Further discussions and evaluations will continue as the commission reviews the specifics of the proposed window placements.