In a pivotal meeting on July 9, 2025, the Nantucket Select Board convened to discuss the contentious issue of short-term rentals and the potential for mediation to resolve ongoing disputes. The atmosphere was charged with anticipation as board members weighed the merits of engaging a mediator to facilitate discussions among stakeholders with differing views on zoning amendments.

George Pucci, a legal advisor, presented a detailed proposal outlining how mediation could work, emphasizing the importance of a neutral third party skilled in zoning laws. He suggested that mediation could help craft a more collaborative document for town meeting, potentially increasing the chances of passing a zoning amendment. This approach aims to regain local control over short-term rental regulations, especially following a recent adverse ruling from the Land Court that overturned a decision by the Zoning Board of Appeals.

The board members expressed a mix of skepticism and cautious optimism. Some recalled previous mediation efforts that had failed to yield satisfactory results, raising concerns about repeating past mistakes. Others, however, highlighted the need for a fresh approach, arguing that a confidential mediation process could allow participants to express their true positions without the pressure of public scrutiny.

Brooke Moore, a board member with mediation training, advocated for a structured process that would invite key stakeholders to participate, ensuring that all voices are heard. She proposed that the board should reach out to those who have previously sponsored warrant articles to gauge their willingness to engage in mediation. This suggestion was met with support, as members recognized the importance of including diverse perspectives in the conversation.

Public comments reflected a range of opinions, with some residents expressing frustration over the prolonged debate and calling for a more straightforward approach to legislation. Others echoed the sentiment that mediation could provide a platform for constructive dialogue, potentially leading to a compromise that would satisfy the community's needs.

As the meeting drew to a close, the board agreed to revisit the mediation proposal in a future session, aiming to gather more input from stakeholders and the public. The urgency of the matter was underscored by the upcoming town meeting, where a unified approach would be crucial for any proposed zoning changes to succeed.

In the coming weeks, the Select Board will continue to navigate this complex issue, striving to balance the interests of residents, business owners, and the broader community as they seek a resolution that reflects the values and needs of Nantucket.