Waukesha Landmarks Commission reviews roof replacement for historic Capels Park home

In a recent meeting of the Waukesha Landmarks Commission, discussions centered around the preservation and restoration of historic properties, highlighting the delicate balance between maintaining architectural integrity and addressing modern needs.

The evening began with a request to replace siding at a property, which was tabled due to the absence of the applicant. However, the focus quickly shifted to a more significant matter concerning the C. Eason House at 406 Windsor Drive, located in the Capels Park Historic District. Built in 1938, this colonial revival home is in need of urgent repairs, particularly its red tile roof, which has suffered visible damage over time.

The homeowner, John Rosenberg, presented his case for replacing the existing clay tile roof with a composite slate roof in a Tuscan clay color, which he believes closely matches the original aesthetic. Alongside the roof replacement, Rosenberg proposed updates to the gutters and chimney flashing, opting for new copper materials to enhance durability and maintain the home's historic character.

Rosenberg expressed his commitment to preserving the home's beauty, despite the challenges he has faced, including a recent rejection of a state tax grant from the historical society. His candid remarks about the property being a "money pit" resonated with the commission, underscoring the financial burdens often associated with maintaining historic homes.

The commission's deliberations reflect a broader commitment to preserving Waukesha's architectural heritage while accommodating necessary updates. As discussions continue, the outcome of this request will not only impact Rosenberg's home but also set a precedent for future renovations within the historic district. The meeting concluded with a sense of urgency and hope for the preservation of Waukesha's rich history, as the commission navigates the complexities of modern restoration efforts.