The Memphis City Council convened on July 8, 2025, to discuss a significant appeal regarding the resubdivision of a portion of Lot 1 of the Save A Lot subdivision, located at 4696 South Third Street. The meeting focused on the request to create a new lot, designated as Lot 3, which would encompass 0.82 acres. This resolution was sponsored by the Division of Planning and Development (DPD) and was identified as case number S25-10.

The meeting began with a motion to appeal the Land Use Control Board's approval of the subdivision, which had been sent down without a recommendation during a prior committee meeting on May 20. Trevian Smith, a planner from DPD, presented the case, explaining that the subdivision would create two separate lots while maintaining the existing uses allowed under the commercial mixed-use zoning designation.

Smith emphasized that the subdivision itself would not alter the types of businesses permitted on the property, which could include various commercial uses. He noted that DPD had approved the subdivision with specific conditions, including restrictions on curb cut access on Shelby Drive.

Councilman Ford raised concerns about community opposition to the project, prompting further discussion about the potential implications of the subdivision. Dr. Lynette Williams, executive director of the Acklena Lakeview Gardens Community Development Corporation, voiced strong opposition, citing fears that the subdivision could threaten the viability of the Save A Lot grocery store, which serves a food desert area. Williams highlighted previous closures of Save A Lot locations and expressed concerns about the introduction of potentially competing businesses, such as an oil change facility, which she deemed inappropriate for the neighborhood.

Council members echoed Williams' sentiments, expressing apprehension about the environmental impact and the potential for new developments to detract from the grocery store's customer base. The discussion revealed a community desire to maintain the grocery store's presence and explore alternatives that would enhance its operations rather than subdivide the property.

The applicant, represented by Wesley Woodridge of the Renaissance Group, clarified that the subdivision aimed to create a marketable lot for future development, although no specific plans were in place at that time. He indicated that the owner sought to increase foot traffic to Save A Lot by potentially selling off the new lot.

As the meeting progressed, council members debated the merits of the appeal, with some advocating for a vote against the subdivision to protect the community's interests. The council ultimately faced a decision on whether to uphold the Land Use Control Board's approval or support the community's appeal.

In conclusion, the Memphis City Council's meeting highlighted significant community concerns regarding the proposed subdivision of the Save A Lot property. The discussions underscored the importance of local input in development decisions, particularly in areas already facing challenges related to food access and environmental health. The council's next steps will determine the future of the property and its impact on the surrounding community.