The Petoskey City Council took a significant step towards preserving the city's historical charm during its meeting on July 7, 2025, by discussing the second reading of a proposed historic district ordinance. City Manager Horne emphasized the importance of this ordinance, which is a prerequisite for joining the Certified Local Government (CLG) program, aimed at enhancing local historic preservation efforts.

The ordinance, which has been crafted with input from the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO), aims to establish a local historic district commission that would oversee the preservation of significant properties within the community. Horne noted the wealth of expertise present in the room, including professional planners and architects, to guide the council through the ordinance's implications.

Council members raised concerns about the potential bureaucratic hurdles that could arise from the ordinance, particularly regarding the impact on property owners wishing to make renovations. Councilman Naptra questioned whether the language of the ordinance was flexible enough to accommodate the needs of commercial property owners, who might face stringent requirements under SHPO guidelines. Architect Rick Newman reassured the council that while there are design standards, they are not as rigid as some might fear, allowing for flexibility in renovations while still preserving historical integrity.

The discussion highlighted the balance between protecting historical assets and ensuring that property owners can maintain and improve their buildings without excessive restrictions. City Planner John Ico Angeli clarified that the ordinance does not automatically create a historic district but rather establishes the framework for a commission to study and recommend potential districts to the council.

As the council deliberated, some members expressed a desire for further research and discussion before moving forward, indicating a willingness to explore the ordinance's implications more thoroughly. The council ultimately decided to table the ordinance for further consideration, ensuring that all voices and concerns are heard before any final decisions are made.

This proposed ordinance represents a crucial step in Petoskey's commitment to preserving its historical character while navigating the complexities of modern development. The council's careful approach reflects a desire to balance community heritage with the practical needs of its residents.