Cheektowaga Council seeks to regulate Airbnb with new permit structure

The Cheektowaga Town Board meeting on July 8, 2025, sparked intense discussions surrounding the regulation of short-term rentals, particularly Airbnb properties. Council members expressed a strong desire to find a balanced approach that addresses community concerns while allowing responsible hosts to thrive.

Councilman Jasinski highlighted the need for a structured permit system, suggesting that permits could be renewed annually, contingent on the absence of complaints. He emphasized the importance of holding irresponsible hosts accountable without punishing those who operate their rentals responsibly. "We need something in place to where we have got some bite to this," he stated, advocating for a system that would allow for revocation of permits in the event of multiple complaints.

Concerns about the existing regulations were also raised, with council members noting contradictions and potential legal issues within the proposed 16-page document. Councilman Benjkowski pointed out the necessity of cleaning up the language and ensuring that the regulations are fair and enforceable. He proposed the creation of a short-term rental commission to oversee compliance and address community issues directly.

The meeting also saw a call for accountability from both hosts and the community. Councilman Thompson urged responsible Airbnb owners to form a committee to monitor and report on problematic rentals, reinforcing the idea that community involvement is crucial for effective regulation. "One bad apple spoils the whole bunch," he remarked, stressing the need for collective responsibility.

As discussions progressed, the board acknowledged the complexities of balancing profit and community safety. Council members agreed that while regulations are necessary, they must not hinder the livelihoods of responsible hosts. The meeting concluded with a consensus to keep the public hearing open for an additional two weeks, allowing for further refinement of the proposed regulations.

The outcome of these discussions could significantly shape the future of short-term rentals in Cheektowaga, as the board seeks to implement a framework that protects residents while supporting local businesses.