Council members debate cultural protection in agricultural tourism bill revisions

Maui County's Council convened on July 8, 2025, to address significant cultural and agricultural issues impacting the community. A key focus of the meeting was the ongoing discussion surrounding a bill aimed at safeguarding indigenous cultures and traditions while balancing agricultural practices and tourism.

The council debated amendments to the bill, which seeks to establish protections against cultural misappropriation and exploitation. Member Rollins Fernandez expressed concerns about the adequacy of these protections, emphasizing the need for stronger language to prevent harm to Hawaiian culture. She highlighted the importance of the newly proposed Department of OEV Resources, advocating for its authority to enforce cultural safeguards effectively.

Member Johnson, who has been a vocal advocate for farmers, underscored the challenges they face, including regulatory hurdles that could hinder their ability to operate. He argued that the bill, despite its imperfections, provides necessary parameters to prevent unregulated practices that could harm both agriculture and cultural integrity.

The council also heard from members representing East Maui, who stressed the dual role of farmers as cultural practitioners. They emphasized the importance of perpetuating traditional practices and educating future generations about indigenous farming methods.

After extensive discussion, the council voted on the bill's amendments, resulting in a majority approval with eight votes in favor and one against. The passage of this motion marks a step forward in addressing the complex interplay between cultural preservation and agricultural development in Maui County.

As the council moves forward, the focus will remain on refining the bill to ensure it adequately protects the community's cultural heritage while supporting local farmers. The ongoing dialogue reflects a commitment to finding a balance that honors both tradition and progress in Maui County.