The Town of Carbondale Historic Preservation Commission convened on July 3, 2025, to discuss updates to the Old Town design guidelines, focusing on the treatment of historic buildings and new construction in the Old Town Residential (OTR) zone. The meeting highlighted the need for a balance between preserving the character of the area and allowing for new development.

Commission member Susanna presented an overview of the existing guidelines, emphasizing the importance of adapting them to apply not only to the historic core but also to future landmarks. She noted that there are currently only a few locally recognized historic buildings in the OTR zone, which necessitates a thoughtful approach to new construction.

Key discussions revolved around site planning issues, including the orientation of buildings, setbacks, and maintaining a mix of building scales. The commission considered whether to encourage new homes to align closely with the street to enhance neighborhood interaction and preserve the area's fabric. Susanna sought feedback on these proposals, indicating that the guidelines should reflect the community's desires while remaining flexible enough to foster creativity.

The conversation also touched on the significance of outbuildings and alleys, with suggestions to include guidelines that address their historical context and functionality. The commission recognized the need to define the character of the OTR zone more clearly, aiming to identify elements that contribute to its unique identity.

As the meeting concluded, members were encouraged to reflect on the proposed guidelines and provide further input in future discussions. The commission aims to finalize the updates by next month, ensuring that the guidelines effectively balance preservation with the potential for new development in Carbondale's historic areas.