The San Antonio Historical Design and Review Commission convened on July 2, 2025, to discuss significant renovations proposed for a property located at 838 East Magnolia Avenue. The meeting focused on the applicant's request to replace wooden windows with aluminum ones and to modify the front door configuration.

The first item on the agenda involved a proposal for a 650-square-foot addition to the property. The commission discussed stipulations for the project, including maintaining the historical integrity of the structure while allowing for necessary modifications. The applicant was granted permission to adjust the height of the addition to align with the existing roof and to ensure that the new materials would not detract from the historical appearance of the building.

Al González, representing the applicant, Michael Salazar, presented the case, emphasizing the need for energy-efficient windows that would match the historical aesthetic of the property. He noted that the proposed windows had been previously approved for use in other historic properties and would enhance the building's energy efficiency. González also provided a model to illustrate how the new design would remain visually consistent with neighboring homes.

The commission's staff recommended against using wood for the new windows, advocating instead for repairs to the existing structure. They also suggested maintaining the historical configuration of the front door rather than altering it. The applicant expressed a desire to remove one of the two front doors, arguing that it would improve the home's functionality while preserving its historical character.

Bárbara Wood Hall, a representative from the Magnolia Avenue Historic District, voiced support for the applicant's proposal, highlighting the importance of adhering to historical preservation guidelines. She submitted a letter from the neighborhood committee endorsing the staff's recommendations and commending their efforts in maintaining the district's historical integrity.

The meeting concluded with no further comments from the commission members, and the discussions underscored the ongoing commitment to balancing modern needs with the preservation of San Antonio's historical architecture. The commission will continue to review the proposal in light of the recommendations and community feedback.