The San Antonio Zoning Commission convened on July 1, 2025, to discuss a significant rezoning request for a property located at 422 Hartline Drive. The proposal seeks to change the zoning from R5 Residential Single Family District and C3NA General Commercial Non-Alcoholic Sales District to C2NA CD Commercial Non-Alcoholic Sales District, allowing for oversized vehicle service and storage. This request has sparked considerable debate among community members and city officials.

The commission received 39 notices regarding the proposal, with 8 in favor and 3 opposed. Notably, there are no registered neighborhood associations within 200 feet of the property. City staff expressed concerns that the proposed use does not align with the established development pattern of the surrounding area, which includes multifamily and residential zones. Staff recommended denial of the request, citing that the C2NA designation still exceeds the intensity suggested for the area near San Antonio International Airport.

Despite these recommendations, the Planning Commission has suggested approval for community commercial use. The property owners, Aldo and Arnold Uribe, defended their request, stating that the current zoning is inappropriate and that the proposed use would help stabilize the area, which has faced issues with crime and unsightly conditions due to previous tenants. They emphasized their long-term ownership of the property and their commitment to maintaining a clean and compliant business environment.

The Uribes highlighted that the current tenant, a mechanic specializing in oversized vehicles, has been operating for about a year and has made efforts to improve the property. They also noted that the area has industrial characteristics, with surrounding properties functioning in similar capacities. The owners believe that the proposed zoning change would not disrupt the community but rather enhance safety and property values.

The meeting concluded without public comment, and the commission is expected to deliberate further on the implications of this rezoning request. The outcome will be crucial for the future development of the Hartline Drive area and its integration into the broader community landscape.