In a heated San Antonio Zoning Commission meeting on July 1, 2025, community members voiced strong opinions regarding a proposed assisted living facility on Santa Gertrudis Street. The atmosphere was charged as residents expressed their concerns about the potential impact on their quiet neighborhood.

Kevin Clark, a local resident and real estate broker, was among the most vocal opponents. He highlighted his worries about property values and the residential character of the area, arguing that the presence of an assisted living facility would deter potential homebuyers. “Would you want to live next to a business?” he asked, emphasizing the importance of maintaining the neighborhood's tranquility for families with young children.

Clark's concerns were echoed by several other residents, including John Staffel and Mariana Castillo, who also opposed the rezoning. They cited fears of increased traffic and noise from emergency vehicles, particularly ambulances, which could disrupt the peaceful environment they cherish. “We don’t want any kind of that in our neighborhood,” Staffel stated, reflecting a common sentiment among those who spoke against the proposal.

In contrast, the applicant, represented by Mr. San Ramon, defended the project, asserting that the facility would not generate significant noise or traffic. He pointed out that the assisted living home would cater to a small number of residents, with plans to start with eight to ten individuals, and emphasized that most residents would not drive. San Ramon also noted that many neighbors had signed in support of the facility, suggesting a divide in community opinion.

The commission discussed the existing zoning regulations, which currently allow for only six residents, while the proposed changes could increase that number to sixteen. This aspect of the proposal raised questions about the balance between community needs and the potential benefits of providing assisted living options.

As the meeting concluded, the commissioners were left to weigh the concerns of the residents against the applicant's assurances. The outcome of this zoning case remains uncertain, but the passionate voices of the community have made it clear that the future of their neighborhood is at stake. The commission's decision will not only affect the proposed facility but also set a precedent for how similar projects are handled in the future.