Historic Preservation Commission faces scrutiny over site visitation and transparency issues

Residents of Roswell raised significant concerns during the City Council's Open Forum on June 30, 2025, particularly regarding the Historic Preservation Commission's (HPC) handling of a proposed project. A local resident, who previously served on the HPC, questioned the commission's adherence to established guidelines, specifically referencing Section 13.7 0.10. This section mandates that any changes to historic properties must not adversely affect their aesthetic, historical, or architectural significance.

The resident expressed frustration over the lack of site visits by the HPC, which were standard practice during their tenure. They emphasized the importance of understanding existing conditions before approving changes. Additionally, concerns were raised about the transparency of the planning process, particularly regarding a proposed event space designed for over 200 guests. The resident noted that public charrettes, which should involve community input, were not conducted, undermining the collaborative spirit expected in such projects.

Another critical issue highlighted was a discrepancy in tree counts related to the Founders Park plan. The resident pointed out a significant difference between the number of trees documented in the plan and those identified in a survey, raising questions about environmental impacts and the accuracy of project assessments.

In response, Mayor Malone acknowledged the concerns and committed to addressing the questions raised. He assured residents that the council would seek to clarify the specifics of the HPC's decision-making process and the project's implications for the community.

This meeting underscored the importance of community involvement and adherence to preservation standards in Roswell, as residents seek to ensure that historic properties are treated with the care and respect they deserve. The council's forthcoming actions will be crucial in addressing these concerns and fostering a more transparent planning process.