A resolution aimed at raising the minimum age for purchasing tobacco, vape products, and marijuana to 21 has sparked significant debate among Milwaukee County Board of Supervisors. The proposal, championed by Supervisor Vincent and inspired by local resident Tyler Roberts, seeks to address concerns about youth access to these substances, particularly near schools.

During the hybrid meeting on June 26, 2025, Supervisor Vincent highlighted the troubling proximity of vape shops to high schools in his district, emphasizing the need for legislative change. He noted that the resolution has already been introduced in the state assembly but stalled in the senate, urging his colleagues to support the initiative to help push it forward.

While many supervisors expressed support, including Supervisor Eglad, who sought to co-sponsor the resolution, dissent emerged from others. Supervisor Martinez voiced concerns that raising the age could further criminalize young adults aged 18 to 21, arguing that it would not effectively address the underlying issues of substance use among youth. Similarly, Supervisor Balinski suggested that the focus should be on regulating retailers rather than penalizing young consumers.

The discussion revealed a broader debate about the age of majority and the responsibilities of young adults in society. Supervisor Alexander pointed out the contradictions in allowing 18-year-olds to serve in the military while restricting their ability to make personal choices about substances.

Ultimately, the board decided to refer the resolution back to committee for further consideration, indicating a willingness to explore amendments that could address concerns about criminalization while still aiming to protect youth. The outcome of this discussion could have significant implications for public health and youth policy in Milwaukee County.