The Dublin Architectural Review Board convened on June 25, 2025, to discuss significant renovations proposed for a historic property, with a focus on maintaining the aesthetic integrity of the neighborhood. The board members expressed a strong preference for Option 1 of the proposed designs, which features a larger hyphen that visually separates the new addition from the original house, enhancing the overall appearance.

Several board members highlighted the importance of preserving the original structure's character while accommodating modern needs. One member noted, “I think it does look more appropriate,” referring to the design's compatibility with the existing architecture. The discussion also touched on the roof lines, with some members expressing concerns about the complexity of Option 1, suggesting it might overwhelm the simpler design of the original house.

The board unanimously supported a waiver for the footprint of the new addition, acknowledging the historical significance of a shed on the property, which contributes to the overall coverage area. “I realize that takes you over the 25%, but I don’t have a problem with that,” one member stated, emphasizing the shed's unique historical features.

Concerns were raised about the window designs in the dormers, with a preference for vertical windows over horizontal ones to maintain a traditional look. The board agreed that adjustments could be made to ensure the windows fit better within the design guidelines.

As the meeting concluded, the board members reiterated their commitment to balancing modern renovations with the preservation of Dublin's architectural heritage. The next steps will involve further refinement of the designs, particularly focusing on roof pitches and window styles, before final approval is granted.