St. Augustine's City Commission has approved significant changes to the city's noise ordinance, aiming to balance the needs of residents and the local hospitality industry. During the meeting on June 23, 2025, the commission voted to treat hotels, motels, and bed and breakfasts similarly to residential zones, implementing a noise reduction policy that will now apply on Thursdays, aligning them with weekday restrictions.

The new ordinance stipulates that noise from sound production devices must not be plainly audible within residences from 10 PM to 7 AM on Sundays through Thursdays, and from 11 PM to 7 AM on Fridays and Saturdays. This change reflects a growing concern among residents about noise disturbances, particularly during the week.

Additionally, the commission has decided that complaints regarding noise disturbances from transient commercial sleeping quarters will be directed to the management of those establishments rather than the police. This shift aims to streamline the resolution process for guests experiencing noise issues.

Public feedback during the meeting highlighted a mix of support and concerns. Scott Maynard from the St. John's County Chamber of Commerce suggested extending nightlife hours on weekends and allowing exceptions for special events, emphasizing the importance of nightlife to the local economy. However, other speakers, including former mayor Scott York, expressed opposition to extending hours, advocating for the need to prioritize residents' peace and quiet.

The commission's decision reflects a careful consideration of community needs, balancing the vibrancy of St. Augustine's nightlife with the rights of residents to enjoy their homes without excessive noise. As the city moves forward with these changes, the implications for both residents and businesses will be closely monitored to ensure a harmonious living environment.