A contentious zoning case took center stage at the Nashville Board of Zoning Appeals meeting on June 20, 2025, as members debated a variance request from Sway Estates for a property located at 1295 Sunny May Drive. The appeal sought to reduce the street setback requirements in the RS 7.5 District, a decision that ended in a tie vote, prompting further discussion and a motion to reopen the public hearing.

The initial motion to approve the variance was made by Mr. Cole and seconded by Mr. Bradford, with support from Mr. Pepper. However, dissent came from Ms. Karpnick, and three members were absent, leading to a split decision. Mr. Ransom expressed his need for more information before casting a vote, indicating uncertainty about the potential impact on neighboring properties. Ms. Johnson also voted against the motion, citing a desire for additional questions to be addressed.

In a surprising turn, the board decided to reopen the public hearing after a motion was made to gather more information. This decision was supported by several members who felt it was essential to hear from both the applicant and any opposition present. The board agreed to allocate three minutes for each side to present their case, ensuring a fair process.

The applicant, represented by Brandon Scott, explained that the request to reduce the setback was necessary due to a creek running through the property, which complicated construction. The proposed structure would be moved forward by approximately 8 to 10 feet to provide better support for the foundation.

As the board prepares for the next steps, including rescheduling the public hearing, the outcome of this case remains uncertain. The decision will significantly impact the development of Sway Estates and set a precedent for future zoning appeals in Nashville.