The San Antonio Historic Compliance and Technical Advisory Board convened on June 20, 2025, to discuss several key items, including a significant request for a certificate of appropriateness regarding window replacements at a historic property.

The meeting began with a reminder that agenda item number five had been postponed, leading to a focus on item six, which involved a request from Jorge Hinojosa, representing the owners of a property located at 34617 East Counter Street. The owners sought approval to replace two windows on the second floor and two on the first floor with aluminum windows, similar to those already installed in the home. However, city staff recommended against this request, urging the use of windows that adhere to the original design guidelines.

Hinojosa explained that the property had undergone renovations since its purchase in February, including landscaping and other improvements. He noted that two of the existing windows were beyond repair due to rot, while the remaining windows had already been replaced with aluminum. Hinojosa argued that replacing the remaining windows with aluminum would maintain a uniform appearance, as the other windows had already been changed.

Board members engaged in a discussion about the historical significance of the windows, with some expressing concerns about preserving the character of the home and the neighborhood. One member highlighted the importance of the original windows, stating that they contribute to the historical narrative of the property and the district. Despite Hinojosa's arguments, the board ultimately sided with the staff's recommendation, emphasizing the need to repair rather than replace the original windows.

A motion was made to deny the request for aluminum windows and to require the use of wooden replacements in line with the historical guidelines. The motion passed unanimously, indicating a strong commitment to preserving the historical integrity of the district.

In addition to the window discussion, the board briefly addressed agenda item seven, which involved a request for a certificate of appropriateness for painting the exterior walls of another historic property. Staff recommended against painting, suggesting that the existing paint be removed using acceptable techniques to maintain the building's historical integrity.

The meeting underscored the board's dedication to preserving San Antonio's historical architecture while balancing the needs of property owners. The next steps for the applicants will involve working with city staff to ensure compliance with the board's recommendations.