The Milwaukee County Committee on Finance convened on June 18, 2025, to discuss the proposed development of affordable housing at McGovern Park, a topic that has sparked significant community debate. The meeting, held in a hybrid format, allowed both in-person and virtual participation, reflecting the importance of the issue at hand.

The session began with public comments, where residents expressed strong feelings about the potential impact of housing development on the park. One long-time resident passionately defended McGovern Park, highlighting its beauty and the emotional connection he has developed over 50 years. He voiced concerns about the degradation of the park and the implications of placing affordable housing within its boundaries, suggesting that alternative locations exist for such developments.

Mark Lauchs, a retired CPA and board member of JFS Housing, spoke in favor of the project, emphasizing the need for safe and affordable housing for seniors. He shared positive experiences from a similar project, Deerwood Crossing, which he believes demonstrates the compatibility of housing and supportive services for older adults.

Contrasting views emerged as other community members, including Sally Callan and Laurie Munsch, raised objections to the proposal. They argued that the project would set a dangerous precedent by allowing housing to be built on parkland, which they believe should remain untouched for public use. Munsch criticized the notion of utilizing parkland for housing, stating that it undermines the integrity of Milwaukee County's parks.

Jan Wilberg, chair of the County Commission on Aging, supported the project, framing it as a necessary response to the aging population's needs. She argued that the current facilities are inadequate and that the proposed development would provide essential services to seniors, addressing issues like social isolation and health disparities.

The discussion highlighted a divide between those advocating for the preservation of green spaces and those emphasizing the urgent need for affordable housing. Kevin Haley, a former parks department employee, echoed concerns about the fiscal implications of the project, questioning the decision to place housing in a park rather than seeking alternative funding solutions for park maintenance.

As the meeting progressed, community members continued to voice their concerns about the lack of transparency and engagement in the planning process. Many expressed skepticism about the necessity of housing in the park, suggesting that other options had not been adequately explored.

The committee's deliberations underscored the complexity of balancing community needs for affordable housing with the preservation of public green spaces. The meeting concluded without a definitive resolution, leaving the future of McGovern Park and the proposed housing project uncertain as further discussions are anticipated.