The St. Augustine Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB) convened on June 18, 2025, to discuss a significant application regarding the demolition and reconstruction of a historic property located at 01:56 Avenida Menendez. The board focused on ensuring that the deconstruction process preserves the integrity of the original structure while allowing for necessary renovations.

During the meeting, board member Mr. McDonald proposed a motion for the approval of the demolition application, emphasizing that the process should be conducted through deconstruction rather than outright demolition. This approach requires careful labeling and inventory of all components to ensure they can be reconstructed in their original design. The motion also stipulates that any salvageable materials should be reused in the reconstruction, with oversight provided by an independent city-appointed engineer. The financial responsibility for this engineer will fall on the property owner.

A key aspect of the motion includes the requirement for accurate photographic documentation of the house as it currently stands. This documentation will serve as a reference during the deconstruction and reconstruction phases to maintain the historical accuracy of the property. Additionally, the engineer will create "as built" drawings that detail the location of each component, ensuring they are reinstalled correctly.

The board unanimously approved the motion, highlighting the collaborative effort to balance preservation with the needs of property owners. The decision reflects the board's commitment to maintaining St. Augustine's historic character while accommodating necessary updates to its architectural landscape. The next steps will involve the property owner coordinating with the appointed engineer to begin the deconstruction process in accordance with the approved guidelines.