In a recent meeting of the St. Augustine Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB), significant discussions centered around the future of a deteriorating historic structure located at 59 Marine Street. The building, which dates back to the 1839 territorial period, has faced extensive scrutiny due to its poor condition and the potential for demolition.

The meeting highlighted a proposal to reconstruct the building while maintaining its historical integrity. The owner’s representative, Mr. Thomas, presented plans to restore the structure to its original 1839 design, incorporating elements from later additions, including porches from the 1890s. The proposal aims to meet the technical feasibility and economic hardship criteria outlined in city code and the Secretary of the Interior Standards.

Board members expressed concerns about the building's structural integrity, particularly its foundations, which have been deemed unsalvageable. Experts indicated that the first floor and walls require significant reconstruction, with estimates suggesting that less than 20% of the original structure remains intact. The discussions also touched on the urgency of addressing the building's condition before the hurricane season, as the current state poses risks to both the structure and surrounding properties.

Public comments reflected a strong community interest in preserving the building. Residents emphasized the importance of historic preservation, arguing that the building is a vital part of the neighborhood's character and history. Some community members expressed frustration over the potential for demolition, advocating for stabilization and restoration efforts instead.

The board's deliberations underscored the tension between preserving historical structures and addressing safety concerns. While some members leaned towards supporting the reconstruction proposal, others called for a more thorough investigation into the building's condition and the feasibility of stabilization efforts.

As the meeting concluded, the board faced the challenge of balancing the preservation of St. Augustine's historical fabric with the practicalities of safety and structural integrity. The outcome of this discussion will likely set a precedent for future preservation efforts in the city, highlighting the ongoing debate over the value of historic buildings in the face of modern challenges. Further evaluations and community input will be crucial as the board moves forward with its decision-making process.