The Allentown City Council convened on June 18, 2025, to address a contentious issue regarding a certificate of appropriateness for a property at 945 Turner Street. The council ultimately voted to deny the request, a decision that has significant implications for the property owner, Dale Frichman, who expressed his frustration during the meeting.

Frichman, who is facing urgent health and safety concerns, explained that he had undertaken extensive repairs on his chimney after a city inspection revealed serious issues, including a blocked liner that posed a carbon monoxide risk. Despite his efforts to comply with city regulations, he claimed he was not adequately informed about the need for a certificate of appropriateness before proceeding with the repairs.

The council members reiterated that any exterior work visible from the public right-of-way in historic districts requires such a certificate. They emphasized that the responsibility to obtain the necessary permits lies with the property owner, not the contractors. Frichman argued that he was unaware of the meetings regarding his property and felt blindsided by the council's decision.

The discussion highlighted the challenges faced by homeowners in historic districts, where regulations can complicate necessary repairs. Council members acknowledged the importance of safety but maintained that adherence to city guidelines is crucial. They encouraged Frichman to work with the Historic Architectural Review Board (HARB) to find a solution that could bring his property into compliance.

As the meeting concluded, Frichman was informed that he has the right to appeal the decision. However, he expressed concern over the financial burden of potentially needing to redo the work he had already completed. The council's decision underscores the ongoing tension between preserving historic integrity and addressing urgent safety needs in Allentown's residential areas.