In a recent meeting of the Ithaca City Project Review Committee, members engaged in a detailed discussion regarding the design and community impact of a new building project. The meeting, held on June 13, 2025, highlighted the importance of aligning architectural aesthetics with community needs and engagement.

One of the central themes of the discussion was the building's design, which some committee members praised for its visual appeal. However, there were significant concerns about the project's functionality and its contribution to the community. Committee member Andy emphasized the need for the design to incorporate more retail space, questioning why the centerpiece of the project was not dedicated to retail. He suggested that a covered area would be more beneficial if it included additional retail options, thereby enhancing the community's experience and interaction with the space.

The conversation also touched on the materials used in the building's construction. Members sought clarity on how the materials would age over time, particularly regarding their maintenance and visual impact. Questions were raised about the building's eventual appearance, especially if it were to turn gray, and how this would blend with the local environment. The committee expressed a desire for visualizations that would depict the building in its final state, allowing for a better understanding of its long-term aesthetic.

Another point of concern was the building's first-floor design, which some members felt lacked engagement with the public. The presence of louvers and garage doors was noted as creating a barrier between the building and the plaza, limiting interaction. Suggestions were made to explore ways to activate this space, potentially through non-commercial uses that would still encourage public interaction.

Overall, the meeting underscored the committee's commitment to ensuring that new developments not only enhance the visual landscape of Ithaca but also serve the community effectively. As the project moves forward, the committee will continue to seek solutions that balance aesthetic appeal with functional community benefits. The next steps will likely involve further revisions to the design based on the feedback provided, ensuring that the final outcome aligns with the community's needs and expectations.