The City of Waukesha Board of Review convened on June 6, 2025, to address property assessment appeals, focusing on the case of Mark and Beth Leverenz regarding their residence at 827 Conifer Court. The meeting began with procedural clarifications and the swearing-in of participants, including the assessors and the Leverenz couple.

The Leverenzes contested their property’s assessed value of $646,300, arguing it should be reduced to $615,000. They presented their case by highlighting discrepancies with comparable properties in their neighborhood, specifically noting that a similar unit was assessed at a lower value of $631,000. They contended that the assessor's valuation was based on the presence of a basement fireplace, which they described as merely an LED backdrop rather than a functional fireplace.

During the discussion, the board and the assessor engaged in a back-and-forth regarding the valuation process. The Leverenzes pointed out that recent sales of comparable homes in their area did not support the higher assessment, citing a recent sale of a three-bedroom home for $525,000. They expressed confusion over the valuation, particularly regarding the perceived value of the fireplace feature.

The assessor, in response, provided a sales comparison sheet that included properties with adjusted sale prices ranging from $625,000 to $658,000. He noted that the assessed value was reflective of the market conditions and the specific features of the Leverenzes' home compared to the sold properties.

The meeting concluded with the board deliberating on the evidence presented. The Leverenzes were reminded that under state law, the burden of proof lies with them to demonstrate that the assessor's valuation was incorrect. The board will issue its findings and decisions regarding the assessed value of the Leverenzes' property following their deliberation.

This meeting underscores the ongoing dialogue between property owners and assessors regarding property valuations, reflecting broader concerns about housing market trends and assessment fairness in Waukesha.