On June 11, 2025, the Saratoga Design Review Commission convened to discuss a significant renovation project for a historic home in Saratoga Springs. The meeting highlighted the delicate balance between modern updates and the preservation of historical integrity, a topic that resonated deeply with the commission members.

The primary focus of the discussion centered around the proposed changes to the home’s facade, particularly the windows. Several commission members expressed concerns about the size and style of the new windows, advocating for the retention of the existing historic windows rather than replacing them with smaller casement windows. The consensus was that double-hung windows would be more appropriate, aligning with the home’s historical character. One member emphasized that the facade is the first impression of the house, stating, “More people will experience your house from the outside than the inside,” underscoring the importance of maintaining an inviting exterior.

Another point of contention arose regarding the removal of two original windows on the first floor, which were to be replaced to accommodate a kitchen countertop. The commission members were adamant that these windows should remain, as they are among the last remnants of the home’s historic fabric. One member remarked, “I can't really see nor can I support removing what's left of the historic fabric of the house,” reflecting a strong sentiment for preserving the building's original features.

The discussion also touched on the proposed new construction elements, including a garage and an entranceway. While some members appreciated the design and materials proposed for the new structures, they reiterated the need for accurate drawings to ensure that the renovations respect the historical context of the home. The chair of the commission noted, “We won’t be able to really move the needle on anything until those accurate drawings are provided,” highlighting the procedural importance of clarity in architectural plans.

In conclusion, the meeting underscored the commission's commitment to preserving the historical integrity of Saratoga Springs while allowing for necessary modern updates. The next steps will involve the homeowners revisiting their plans with their architect to address the commission's feedback, particularly regarding the windows and overall design coherence. As the project progresses, the balance between modernization and preservation will remain a critical focus for both the homeowners and the Design Review Commission.